Subud Vision - Feedback
This is a well written article containing important points and illustrations. Congratulations.
I don't know if it was a mistake to stop having contributions from others in the Pewartas, but I do remember enjoying the articles by Pak Sudarto almost as much as the advice, jokes and stories he told in his house.
I am one who reveres Bapak. I revere him for connecting us directly to the Power of God, for continually telling us that a teacher always holds something back, but that Bapak gave us everything and we now have to receive it directly. That is what brought me into Subud: the absence of a guru and of any kind of teaching or philosophy.
I remember Bapak testing someone and saying, 'this brother will stand on his own two feet'. I remember that soon after Raphael Hoegh-Krone wrote to Bapak about some experiences he had had, Bapak said in a talk, 'At last someone who can receive like Bapak'. I remember that Bapak had a prayer, 'Let me not come alone to heaven'; I was deeply moved by the very strong sense of loneliness I got when first heard this .
It is certainly possible that some of the things Bapak did gave encouragment to those who wanted to set him up as a guru, but he made it clear in his talks that he did not want this. I am convinced that it is posible to revere Bapak as a wise and loving father or elder brother, without setting him up as the One Source or as a guru. I find sad and dangerous the binary polarising into Bapakists (horrible word) and anti-Bapakist factions that you seem to have experienced and which appears to be gaining ground. One of the glorious things about Subud is the huge variety of characters in our association. It is something to celebrate, perhaps chiefly by meeting the great challenge to respect each other's different views and paths.
Thanks for the feedback. Jonathan died last year. He was quite elderly. We were very pleased to have got his article with its unique historical perspective ( and incidentally his interesting observations about the founder of Scientology )
Add Feedback to this page / Communicate with us
Use the form below to
- Send your own response to the opinions expressed above
- Request password reminder
- Request addition to or removal from the list of contributors who get instant email notification of changes to this page
- Complain about a guidelines breach.
Problems filling in the form? To get help, please email firstname.lastname@example.org